Blundstone 510 Vs 558 | Which Boot Is Right For You?

Shoes Fulcrum

“As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.” I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you) if you purchase something through the links provided on this website. Read more

Blundstone 510 Vs 558

Blundstone 510 Vs 558 | Which Boot Is Right For You?

Spread the love by sharing because sharing is caring.

Blundstone is a brand that is very close to my heart. Blundstone has been in business for nearly 153 years, and its boots reflect that expertise and experience.

Blundstone boots have grown in popularity in recent years, and I can see why. They are long-lasting, comfortable, and fashionable all at the same time. Individuals enjoy wearing them to work, on informal trips, and everywhere in between.

The Blundstone 510 and 558 are two of the brand’s most popular boots. The Blundstone 510 is a terrific all-around boot with a classic design. On the other hand, Blundstone 558 has a more powerful and sophisticated appearance and is designed for individuals who need a boot for tougher situations.

I can’t wait to explain each boot in detail and help you determine which one is best for you. Well, let’s get started!

Comparison Table Of Blundstone 510 Vs 558

Thick, Non-marking outsole, Good GripBlundstone 510Blundstone 558
Design And StyleClassic, Versatile, Rustic LookSleek, Modern, Dressier look
Materials UsedDurable leather upper, Shock absorbing solePremium leather upper, Lightweight PU midsole, Slip resistant, TPU outsole
Comfort And FitThe generous toe box, Removable Insole, Ease of slip onSnug Fit, Contoured EVA footbed, Easy to slip on
Durability And LongevityResistant to wear and tear, Can last for yearsHigh-quality construction,Long lasting performance
Sole And TractionThe slip-resistant outsole, Good gripHigh-quality construction, Long lasting performance
Suitable Activities And EnvironmentEveryday wear, Light hiking, Gardening, Manual laborBusiness casual, Urban environments, Light hiking, All day wear

Features And Benefits Of Blundstone 510 Vs 558

Let’s examine the Blundstone 510 vs 558 features and benefits.

Design And Style

  • One of the most noticeable distinctions between the Blundstone 510 and 558 is their design and style
  • The 510 has a classic and simple design that is appropriate for everyday use, but the 558 has a rugged and distressed appearance that lends itself to a more rustic appeal. 
  • Both boots have the famous Chelsea-style construction with elastic gussets, although the sole on the 558 is significantly thicker.


material of Blundstone 510 Vs 558
  • Both the Blundstone 510 and 558 have high-quality leather uppers, but the 558 contains water-resistant leather that allows it to be worn in rainy weather. 
  • The 510 features a detachable EVA footbed, whereas the 558 has a polyurethane footbed
  • Both boots have TPU outsoles, but the 558 has a thicker sole that provides additional cushioning and support.

If you want to know aboutBlundstone Antique Brown VS Rustic Brown: Which Is Better? read this.

Comfort And Fit

comfort of Blundstone 510 Vs 558

The Blundstone 510 and 558 both provide a comfortable and secure fit, however, there are some differences. 

  • The Blundstone 558 is more comfortable than the 510 because it has EVA removable footbed with PORON XRD. 
  • The 510 features a slightly narrower toe box, making it unsuitable for persons with wider feet. 
  • The 558 features a spacious toe box that allows for free movement of the toes, and the elastic gussets on the sides of the boots create a secure fit that keeps the boots in place. 
  • The padded collars on both boots give extra comfort around the ankles.


  • The Blundstone 510 and 558 are both built to last and are quite durable. 
  • The leather uppers are durable and can withstand heavy wear, while the TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) outsoles give good traction and are resistant to oil, acid, and organic fat. 
  • The 558 features a thicker sole that may provide additional durability and longevity.

Sole And Traction

  • The Blundstone 510 and 558 both include TPU outsoles that give good traction on a range of surfaces
  • The 558 has a thicker sole that may provide additional cushioning and support, making it appropriate for more demanding activities like hiking and camping.

If you want to know about Blundstone Thermal Vs Regular | Which Is Healthier For Your Feet? read it.

Real World Testing

Real-world testing is an important part of determining a product’s worth, and the Blundstone 510 and 558 boots are no exception. I looked at reviews and feedback from people who have used both boots and discovered some useful information.

  • The Blundstone 510 and 558 have both received great marks for durability and lifespan. Customers have stated that they have used these boots for several years with no significant wear or damage. They have also been praised for their ability to perform effectively in a variety of tasks such as hiking, farming, and construction labor.
  • In terms of comfort, the Blundstone 510 has received more positive feedback than the 558. The design of the 510 provides exceptional support and cushioning, making them perfect for all-day use. On the other hand, customers have stated that the 558 is not as comfortable as the 510 and that it requires a break-in period before becoming comfortable.
  • Regarding the sole and traction, both boots have been complimented for their slip-resistant soles, which provide good grip and stability on a variety of surfaces. However, some customers note that the Blundstone 558 has a little harder sole than the 510, making it better suited for more difficult terrains.
  • When it comes to specific activities and environments, the Blundstone 510 is more versatile and ideal for everyday usage, such as walking, running errands, and light work. The Blundstone 558, on the other hand, is better suited for more demanding tasks such as hiking, farming, and construction work due to its tougher design.
Real World Testing

If you want to know about Ugg Tasman read this Are Ugg Tasman Slippers Unisex? | Detail Guide

Pros And Cons

Blundstone boots are known for their high quality and longevity, but, like every product, they have their pros and cons. Let’s compare the pros and cons of the Blundstone 510 and 558 to see which boot has more benefits and fewer drawbacks.

Blundstone Boot 510

Classic and versatile designLimited ankle support
High-quality leatherNot warmth
Slip-resistant sole
Suitable  for work and casual wear

Blundstone Boot 558

Stylish and modern designHeavier and less flexible
Premium black leatherLess versatile
Steel toe for added protection 
Suitable for  rigorous outdoor pursuits
Slip-resistant sole


I hope you will be now much more familiar with the difference between Blundstone 510 Vs 558.

The Blundstone 510 is a good choice for people seeking a classic, adaptable, and long-lasting boot that can be worn in a range of settings and activities.

The Blundstone 558, is a more durable and protective option for people who need a boot that can resist tougher weather and higher workloads. 

Finally, the Blundstone 510 or 558 is a matter of personal preference, intended use, and budget. Both boots are high-quality, dependable, and fashionable, but the 558 is a better choice for individuals who need greater protection and durability, and the 510 is a more versatile and classic selection.

Based on my comparison, I recommend the Blundstone 510 for individuals who value comfort, style, and versatility, and the Blundstone 558 for those who require a heavier-duty and more protective boot for work or outdoor sports.

In my conclusion, whichever Blundstone boots you purchase, you can be confident that you are investing in a high-quality and durable piece of footwear that will last for years.


What size are Blundstone boots?

Blundstone boots often run true to size, but it’s always a good idea to consult the brand’s size chart before purchasing. Because some styles may run a little large or small, it’s important to complete your research.

Is it acceptable to wear Blundstone boots in the rain or snow?

Yes, Blundstone boots are weather-resistant and suited for use in rainy or snowy circumstances. It is important to keep in mind, however, that they are not waterproof and may not be suited for use in extreme weather situations.

What is the lifespan of Blundstone boots?

Blundstone boots have a variable lifespan based on style, frequency of usage, and amount of care. A pair of Blundstone boots can survive for several years with proper care and maintenance.

Are Blundstone boots appropriate for the workplace?

Blundstone boots are used for a variety of occupations, including construction, farming, and manufacturing. They are well-known for their durability and comfort, and many versions have slip-resistant soles for extra security.

Is it appropriate to wear Blundstone boots with a suit or dress pants?

Blundstone boots are a timeless style that can be dressed up or down for any occasion. While they may not be appropriate for formal occasions, they can be worn with dress pants or a suit for a more casual approach.

Are Blundstone boots vegan?

Blundstone boots are not vegan because they are mostly comprised of leather. Even so, the business also offers several models manufactured partially or entirely of synthetic materials, which may be a decent option for individuals who prefer not to wear leather.

Can I use Blundstone boots with orthotics?

Yes, many Blundstone boots have detachable insoles that can be replaced with custom orthotics or inserts to provide additional comfort and support.

hammad qadir

About Author:

Hammad Qadir is a passionate fashion blogger with a passion for shoes, spanning over seven years. As the driving force behind “” he offers unparalleled insights into iconic brands like Crocs, Hey Dude, and Birkenstock. With a collection of a hundred pairs, his expertise extends to industry giants like Nike and Adidas. Through insightful reviews and recommendations, Hammad guides readers to their perfect pair. Hammad’s knack for differentiating between brands and guiding readers makes him a trusted authority. Active on Quora, Reddit, Medium, LinkedIn, and Pinterest, he fosters engagement and shares exclusive content. Read more...

Spread the love by sharing because sharing is caring.
Scroll to Top